Planting seeds or seedlings?

Dec 19, 2016by Farmer Liz

Its taken me a little while to learn this, but I think I've now figured out which veges to sow directly in the soil as seeds and which to raise as seedlings and then plant in my garden, so I thought I'd share with you what has worked for me so far.

radish seedlings peeping through the mulch

At first I tried to plant everything as seeds directly in the garden, but I wasn’t happy with the results, too much work to thin the seedlings and some didn’t sprout at all. So then I tried raising seedlings, it took me a while to realise that I needed to use a good seed-raising mix, and I prefer to use toilet rolls than the seedling trays that bought seedlings come in. I wrote more about raising seedlings here.

starting veges in pots and toilet rolls (photo from last spring)

Then I decided that I wanted to grow root crops, and they don’t transplant well, so I had to think about how to do this. I observed that tiny brassicas were popping up through the mulch, and they must have come from the ones that I’d left to go to seed. Previously I had thought that seeds couldn't sprout through the mulch, but I was wrong. This is the method that I use to plant carrots, swedes, turnips and radishes:

Push mulch aside and dig a shallow trench
Fill trench with seed-raising mix
Sprinkle seed thinly as humanly possible so you don’t have too much thinning to do later
Pat the seeds in the seed-raising mix and lightly cover with a little mulch
The seeds will sprout through the mulch and then you just need to thin them a little
I try to write down what I’ve planted where so I know which seeds didn’t sprout (and should be thrown out), and which were good.

For more about growing and using root vegetables, see my post here.

For brassicas, I throw a few seeds around the brassica area of the garden. If I have new seeds that I want to try, I’ll plant them in a shallow tray of seed-raising mix first, to see how they sprout and then transplant them later. If we are having a bad year for slugs, I start the brassicas outside the garden to give them a chance to get bigger.

The entire bed, planted with carrots, radishes, onions, turnip and swede

Plants like tomatoes, capsicum, beans, peas, basil and other herbs, I plant in the toilet rolls, and if there’s no room in the garden yet, or the weather isn’t quite right, I keep potting them into larger pots until I’m ready to plant them in the garden.

Do you plant seeds directly in your garden?

eBooks By Eight Acres

View all

eBook - Make Your Own Natural Soap

eBook - Our Experience with House Cows

eBook - A Beginner's Guide to Backyard Chickens and Chicken Tractors

eBook - Advanced Natural Soapmaking Techniques

eBook - Grow Your Own Vegetables

5 tips for growing your own veggies to save on your food bill

While mindlessly scrolling Facebook I saw a post which was an article from 2017 that had been reshared. The title of ...
Posts about Growing Vegetables on Eight Acres

I started my first vegetable garden in 2008 after I was inspired by a DVD in which Peter Cundall (from Gardening Aust...
Book review: Modern Slow Cooker

I first bought a slow cooker after our first experience butchering a steer at home. Unfortunately, we didn't know tha...
Weird vegetables in my sub-tropical garden

I've had some questions about the weird vegetables in my sub-tropical food garden, so here are some details for you. ...
Tips for starting vegetables from seeds

Its time to start planting for spring, and the cheapest way to grow your own vegetables is ito start from seeds (and ...